| The following warnings occurred: | |||||||||||||||
Warning [2] Undefined property: MyLanguage::$archive_pages - Line: 2 - File: printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code PHP 8.0.30 (Linux)
|
![]() |
|
The Three Musketeers - Printable Version +- Forums (http://www.brotherhoodofdoom.com/doomForum) +-- Forum: Doom Arts (http://www.brotherhoodofdoom.com/doomForum/forumdisplay.php?fid=6) +--- Forum: Doom DVDs (http://www.brotherhoodofdoom.com/doomForum/forumdisplay.php?fid=11) +--- Thread: The Three Musketeers (/showthread.php?tid=4580) Pages:
1
2
|
The Three Musketeers - Drunk Monk - 08-16-2018 Starting this thread not with the awesome Hobbs one but with the dumb 2011 one with the CGI battle blimps. We watched it in Geneva in French. When it came on, I dissed it appropriately, but those actors are Tara's generation so she wanted to see it through. And then, it was filmed in Versailles and the final Rochefort duel is atop Notre Dame, so it became interesting on that 'we were just there' level. But it's still dumb overall. Horribly dumb. Dumbest 3M flick ever. RE: The Three Musketeers - Dr. Ivor Yeti - 08-17-2018 So dumb that I forgave it. Still hating “Brat-Pack” version with a near-Lynchian hate. RE: The Three Musketeers - Drunk Monk - 09-09-2018 Me ‘Now do you see why I dissed that other version so hard?’ T ‘Totally. That other one was completely lame compared to this.’ After Geneva I made my daughter promise to watch the ‘73 version with me. She loved it. We both laughed so hard. It’s still great on every level, especially those background details. What a cast. What great fights. Hobbs still rules. Spot on comic timing. Pick up your damn sword D’artagnan! A true masterpiece that stands the rest of time. Even better because of the locations having now been to Versailles (spent 2+ hours in line looking at those damn gates) and that gothic wonder of the Toledo cathedral. Not sure if we’ll get to 4 musketeers before she leaves. I warned her of the tragic death and she hates those. RE: The Three Musketeers - Dr. Ivor Yeti - 09-09-2018 Best leave her with just the Three then. That last fight in Four was magnificent, but the death is tragic. Best version. Screenplay by George MacDonald Fraser (Flashman books). Best acting, directing, fighting. RE: The Three Musketeers - Drunk Monk - 09-10-2018 She may just watch it on her own. I'll probably watch it on my own if we don't watch it together. But yeah, giving the comedic style of 3M, the deaths in 4M are harsh. I remember. I still luv Reed's performance most of all. He just nails Athos. RE: The Three Musketeers - Drunk Monk - 02-17-2021 I can hear that Yeti "squeee!" as soon as he gets to who's playing Milady. Quote:Feb 11, 2021 10:30pm PT Or maybe the Yeti just noticed the pic and squeed prematurely. RE: The Three Musketeers - Dr. Ivor Yeti - 02-17-2021 I’m inclined to dislike all versions of 3M that aren’t the One True version. I’ll gladly watch the new Milady (the first who can exceed Fay Dunaway) (?) and revile the rest of the effort. I’d like to be pleasantly surprised. I love the book; if idiots can just stick to the book and to the correct fighting style... RE: The Three Musketeers - cranefly - 02-17-2021 I think there's some premature condemning of all flavors but the original. For one, let's not too hastily forget 1973's They Were Called Three Musketeers But They Were Four. ... Okay, now we can forget. RE: The Three Musketeers - Greg - 02-17-2021 When we say best version, we do mean the one with Gene Kelly, right? RE: The Three Musketeers - Drunk Monk - 02-17-2021 Gene's version was good too. And then there's this... ![]() As a footnote, we watched the first hour or so of the York/Reed/Chamberlain/Finlay/Dunaway/Heston/Lee/Miligan/WELCH&Hobbs version a week or so ago. Stacy needed something to clear her palette before bed after watching the first ep of Remember Me (http://www.brotherhoodofdoom.com/doomForum/showthread.php?tid=5391&pid=44903#pid44903). It's available on Amazon Prime and it is still SO GOOD. Every scene is perfect. Love that film. RE: The Three Musketeers - Dr. Ivor Yeti - 02-17-2021 I rewatched it last week as well. Perfect. Gene Kelly's version was good, too. CF, it is never too early to condemn a heresy. RE: The Three Musketeers - cranefly - 02-17-2021 A question about the photo of Jackie Chan, Sammo Hung, and Yuen Biao. That's from Meals on Wheels, which I saw a long time ago -- possibly at one of the San Jose Cameras or the Towne or someplace else. LCF has never seen it, and for centuries now I've been striving to remedy that situation as well as enjoy it again. But it seems to be one of those rare elusive Jackie Chan films that gets limited distribution. DM, any idea why that is? I see that Meals on Wheels gets mentioned a few times on Doom, but has never had a proper review -- unless it got lost in one of the earlier DOOM iterations. RE: The Three Musketeers - Drunk Monk - 02-17-2021 I think WoM available on Amazon Prime. I watched it again after visiting Barcelona to see if I recognized any locations (I did - one of the Plazas). I'm surprised I didn't review it. And it's Wheels on Meals. The common story is that the film canisters only had partial titles and they got reversed somehow screwing up the title. I worked in a theater with ED & LB when we were still using film and that just doesn't make sense. Tell LCF it is a must see. Both of the Jackie/Sammo/Yuen films WoM & Dragons Forever are choreographic masterpieces. Oh look - it's on my top Martial Arts flicks on Amazon piece: Quote: RE: The Three Musketeers - Dr. Ivor Yeti - 02-17-2021 Vincent Cassel as Athos in the upcoming French version (Bah! What do The French know about Musketeers, anyway?). His father was Jean-Pierre Cassel, who played King Louis in the One True Version. RE: The Three Musketeers - cranefly - 02-18-2021 Dammit, I knew it was an ass-backward title, but I managed to double ass-backward it in my mind and make un-ass-backward. The logic I heard for titling it Wheels on Meals was that there had been too many titles already that year starting with M, so the powers that be opted to just switch the title around to improve the marketing. That logic seems very suspect, so I'm inclined to think it's correct. As for Vincent Cassell, he's impressed me so many times with his acting and his physicality. So I'm seeing his involvement as a major positive. |